LDS has birthplace as "Of, , Coshocton, Ohio", but son Noah A. Garlits' 1880 and 1890 census records list Pennsylvania as the birthplace for both his parents.
Henry Garlits listed on http://www.garlitz.org/henry_of_henry_1805.html has a birthdate of 20 Jan 1805 instead of 20 Jan 1803. This would be the same Henry that the LDS has as "Henry Garlitz, b. 26 Jan 1805 , , Pennsylvania". Seems coincidental enough to suspect that these two are the same person, although they have different spouses identified.